Hmm I loved the buy one get one free :33 [I think I had buy 2 get one free when I bought my stuff 0-o I duno] Haha but yeah No worries on the shipping its waay cheap from u free gift with each purchase depends...on what you get Maybe you could buy a ton of different kinds of necklaces to wear it on, and they get the usual one thats leather and for the free gift they get to pick a other kind

I duno, also Imma upload some pix of me with it on ASAp ;D and I might start selling stuffed animals on etsy [when i get a chance to make um LOL]

I say... I get free merchandise. For life. I'll pick it up next time I'm in your general vicinity

Well... I'm stealing this idea from Kidrobot, maker of Munnys, but when you buy something from them, they're "blind boxes" so you don't actually know what you're getting. There are like, 10 options, and some are rarer than others, and you don't know what you're getting until you open the box.
Perhaps, you could include a free little extra something, something simple.

Just an idea...
Not really clear.

I'm tired and sick so... I don't really have anything great to say.

I say free gift or buy one get one free Free things always make me want to buy stuff XD haha

Tough decision, but I went with "Free Gift with Each Purchase." I liked the sound of buy one get one free as well! The free shipping sounded nice, but honestly, your shipping prices aren't that expensive. So that's my two cents for whatever they are worth to you